long time resident here (grew up, went to school, and work here). married with a kid on the way now so figured I'd drop some knowledge for anyone struggling out there.
real talk: NYC is a gold mine if you stop wasting time on apps like Feabie or trying to find the one big girl in the West Village or Williamsburg. most of the advice floating around on here is from tourists or shut-ins.
if you're down for cold approaching, location is everything:
- Astoria: solid if you want white/asian professionals. spots like Break Bar or the Bohemian Hall are easy starting points. Clubs on Steinway and under the subway on 31st Ave always have big girls in them.
- The Bronx & Uptown: hit the Grand Concourse (somewhere between Yankee Stadium and Fordham Road) or Dyckman in Manhattan for Dominican and Puerto Rican spots, especially hookah lounges and dance clubs.
- New Jersey or Fulton Mall in Downtown Brooklyn: where you want to be for Black women. RIP the Lane Bryant on Fulton.
- Corona: goto for Mexican and Central American.
- College/Uni spots: if you're young enough to blend in, hierarchy goes St. John's / CUNY > NYU > Fordham > Columbia (and grad students beat undergrads every time).
- Random wildcards: The Irish Exit in Penn Station is surprisingly effective, and the bars right around Broadway right after shows let out are ripe (you'll overpay for drinks, but no covers).
- Day game & events: Queens Night Market or Mets games are peak for down to earth, middle-class girls with unreal racial diversity. Also, bookstores in Manhattan are low-key my highest success rate spots with built in conversation starters.
- The GOAT: I never actually went to Comic-Con, but just walking around the perimeter when it's going on... the view speaks for itself.
if cold opens aren't your thing:
- Hospitals: make friends with people working healthcare, or date nurses (nurses love to snack, private hospitals skew whiter).
- Plus-size fashion events: a lot of them are free or cheap. Wooplus had a runway show a while back, just tell people you're in content marketing or doing PR coverage. Met a few recognizable models through those circles.
- Facebook Dating: genuinely the best app for this city if you actually use it right. It will learn your physical preferences.
- Structured social activities : board game clubs, local bar trivia, or just taking a random continuing-ed class at a CUNY campus.
stay completely away from: West Village, Williamsburg, tourists, and actual fetish/kink dating sites (too many weird power dynamics and people who want to roleplay online for six months before meeting).
one last thing: treat whoever you meet with actual respect. most people are just trying to live their lives and have a good time. don't approach it like you're trying to "trick" someone or run a psyop. especially in NYC, women are exhausted by games. if you're a straightforward guy who treats them well and doesn't make them chase, the bar here is actually surprisingly low unless you're trying to date girls who only want a sugar daddy.